- Dec 6, 2005
- So. Oregon
heres a big Q. kellogii with some signs of decay. i bid it as a removal, based on the pics would guys do other wise?
All trees, like all people, have issues.Yep, that tree looks like it has issues.
The mistletoe is what does it in for me. You'd NEVER be able to cut it all out, the tree is too infected.
the mushrooms and decay are spread out about 50% circumference.
sounds pretty solid most of the way around
id agree with the Armillaria, no resistograph in the valley that i know of yet
structure does look good above the base.
i agree with brian on the decay from past experience but the canopy is pretty healthy, black oak have an open canopy.
im enjoying the responses and differing view points
Have you tried probing the roots/base with a steel rod? Although this does'nt always show up the decay either as sometimes the roots decay from underneath first so the top remains fairly solid.
Good management would say to remove the tree. There are options, but how viable are they for your customers pocketbook? Save the ISA wine and cheese tactics for those who have the money to gamble, You know there are dying/dead roots on a good portion of that tree. Along comes a stormy summer day, SMASH! thru the house, not good.
This sounds like a tactic borne of Mogen David, mind rotted by rotgut, and a view of trees as things to cut down.Save the ISA wine and cheese tactics for those who have the money to gamble, You know there are dying/dead roots on a good portion of that tree. Along comes a stormy summer day, SMASH! thru the house, not good.
Also you say the canopy looks fairly healthy? Did you see it in full leaf or are you going by signs of die back? I've again seen trees with no signs of die back, but the foliage can be sparse/er with smaller leaves, yet the decay was advanced, so not always a good indicator.
Basically fell it.
we have a tendency in our society to attempt to 'save' that which is too far gone.
Just look at our health care industry..