What I seen done in this video is what I would call just roughing everything in. Not the final finished product of stuff that wasnt shown.
I agree, likely would have been good to have made it more clear that it was not the finnished product as there were still a lot of rough spots and things that looked like they could stand a little more evening up.
There were a few things I do differently on that saw, only because I did them much the same way then found there was a better way that gave more power with less change to the actual cylinder.
None the less hats off to the guy, a lot of work to put DIY videos together and takes some guts as they are open for everyone to pick at.
As for giving secrets away, I have seldom found it to be much a problem. I'd say there are about 4 groupings of people working on engines:
-Those that just don't get it and likely never will, giving them info changes what they can do very little.
-Those that get a bit of a handle on it, but not to the level of really understanding wats going on which kind of limits how far they will take things. These are the guys that make the ports wider, raise the exhaust 1mm, lower the intake 2mm and advance the timing half the width of the flywheel key. Sure some of them open up shop and build saws, but a lot of problems and hit or miss outcomes. These guys often get bits of info, but often is simply miss applied. Recently recieved a saw to rework for some one, were talking a work saw with nearly 200 degs exhaust duration, almost as much on the intake and compression in the 130s. Sad saw even with muffler opened up was truely worse than stock.
-Then there are the guys that will get there anyway, they got the smarts, do their homework, equip their shop, some of them don't share much, they figure they got there on their own and everyone else should too. Downfall of this, is they don't get the full benifit of info that is share behind the open forums.
-The last group is the ones that understand engines have the shop together to do the work, but they bounce ideas and such back and forth with others, like a team of experts working on a problem sharing information.
Sure there is a time and place to keep quiet, someone passes a good idea along, best not to start a thread comming off like it was your idea.